Ebook Free Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M
We will certainly reveal you the very best and simplest way to obtain book Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M in this globe. Bunches of collections that will assist your obligation will be right here. It will make you really feel so excellent to be part of this web site. Ending up being the member to consistently see what up-to-date from this publication Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M site will certainly make you feel ideal to look for guides. So, just now, and also right here, get this Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M to download and install as well as save it for your priceless deserving.
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M
Ebook Free Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M
Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M. Checking out makes you better. That states? Numerous sensible words claim that by reading, your life will certainly be much better. Do you think it? Yeah, confirm it. If you require guide Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M to read to show the sensible words, you can see this web page flawlessly. This is the site that will provide all guides that most likely you need. Are the book's compilations that will make you feel interested to check out? Among them below is the Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M that we will certainly propose.
As one of the home window to open up the brand-new world, this Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M provides its incredible writing from the author. Published in one of the preferred publishers, this publication Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M becomes one of the most desired books recently. Really, guide will certainly not matter if that Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M is a best seller or otherwise. Every book will certainly still give finest sources to get the user all finest.
Nevertheless, some individuals will seek for the very best vendor book to read as the first referral. This is why; this Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M is presented to fulfil your necessity. Some individuals like reading this publication Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M because of this popular publication, however some love this because of preferred author. Or, numerous likewise like reading this book Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M due to the fact that they actually need to read this publication. It can be the one that truly love reading.
In getting this Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M, you may not constantly pass strolling or riding your motors to the book stores. Obtain the queuing, under the rain or hot light, as well as still search for the unknown book to be in that book shop. By visiting this web page, you can just search for the Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M as well as you can find it. So now, this time is for you to choose the download web link and also acquisition Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M as your very own soft data book. You can read this book Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M in soft data just as well as save it as all yours. So, you do not need to hurriedly place the book Narratives Of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings Of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies In Late Antiquity And Early Islam, No. 14), By Fred M into your bag all over.
How and why did Muslims first come to write their own history? The author argues in this work that the Islamic historical tradition arose not out of "idle curiosity," or through imitation of antique models, but as a response to a variety of challenges facing the Islamic community during its first several centuries (ca. seventh to tenth centuries C.E.). The narratives that resulted focused on certain themes of Islamic origins, selected to legitimize particular aspects of the Islamic community and faith in one or another. These included the need to establish the status of Muhammad (d. 632) as prophet, to affirm that the community to which they belonged was the direct descendant of the original community founded by the Prophet, to explain (and justify) Muslim hegemony over vast populations of non-Muslims in the rapidly growing Islamic empire, and to articulate different positions in the ongoing debate with the Islamic community itself over political and religious leadership. An examination of these key themes of early Islamic historiography and the issues generating them is placed in the context of other styles of legitimation in the early Islamic community, including such methods as appeals to piety and genealogy.
Narratives of Islamic Origins is a groundbreaking work that represents the first comprehensive tradition-critical account of the origins and rise of Arab-Islamic historiography, and is essential reading for all historians of medieval Islamic history and civilization, and for all those interested in the historiography of comparative civilizations.
- Sales Rank: #1046702 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Darwin Press, Incorporated
- Published on: 1998-05
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.75" h x 6.50" w x 1.25" l, 1.75 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 358 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
About the Author
Fred M. Donner is Professor of Near Eastern History, The Oriental Institute and the University of Chicago, where he is the Chair, Department of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations. He is the author of numerous studies on early Islamic history and historiography.
Most helpful customer reviews
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful.
An important contribution to the study of how Islam arrived.
By A Customer
A very important study that counters much of the arguments put forth by revisionist historians like Wansborough and Crone. He delves into the nature of the sources, the formation of identity during the earliest phases and ways of understanding the nature of the Movement (Islam). His style is refreshingly clear and consice and his scholarship exhaustive. A must read for any student of Islamic history.
25 of 25 people found the following review helpful.
Lucid and Convincing
By Tron Honto
This work is a key contribution in the debate over the historicity and reliability of the early Islamic tradition. Donner's work provides an alternative, redactionary and critical approach to the rise of narrative and historical texts in early Muslim narratives to the `skeptical' approach-associated primarily with the like of P. Crone, M. Cook, and J. Wansborough among others. In the end, he endorses a critical approach to traditional accounts of Islamic origins but one that does not reject its broad outlines. Though this feature distinguishes and orients the argument of the book, it by no means exhausts the book's contents.
The main aim of the work is to address this straightforward question: "Why did Muslims begin to narrate and eventually compose history?" His argument answers this question by examining the evolution of salient narrative themes that predominately arise as result of efforts to procure legitimacy. Hence, the evolution of historical writing is pushed for by the function it serves for establishing the legitimacy of one or another groups' claim to legitimacy. The resulting picture goes far in helping explain some of the odd idiosyncrasies of early Islamic history-e.g., the absence of chronology.
I found the general outlines of the book to be quite convincing; however, the devil is in the details, as it is said. Critical examination of hadith may lead us to confer that it is plausible that the first four caliphs were Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali in that order, that the Battle of the Camel and Siffin occurred, but the details-copiously provided in Islamic tradition-remain highly dubious. In this sense, the ramifications of the book's arguments, even if valid, are not fully drawn and remain open to investigation.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
A terrific read
By L. Wolf
Fred Donner teaches in the department of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations at the University of Chicago. He is one of the world's foremost scholars of early Islamic history, and he has published three controversial books on the subject: "The Early Islamic Conquests" (1981), "Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing" (1998), and "Muhammad and the Believers: At the Origins of Islam" (2010).
In "Narratives of Islamic Origins", Donner advances a number of important claims: (1) the Qur'an (in large part, if not in whole) can be confidently dated to the time of Muhammad; (2) while some hadith traditions may derive from the time of Muhammad, many such traditions (including those collected in hadith manuals widely accepted by Sunni Muslims) post-date the time of Muhammad by decades or more; (3) Muhammad and his early followers were largely if not primarily motivated by piety (ethical monotheism), rather than social, economic, or (non-nationalist) political considerations, though such worldly motives may have played some role in the early conquests (see pp. 217-20 of "Muhammad and the Believers: At the Origins of Islam" for an argument that Arab nationalism was a product - not a cause - of the initial expansion of Islam); (4) the earliest Muslims did not sharply distinguish themselves from Jews, Christians, and perhaps even Zoroastrians; (5) Muslims did not develop an historical consciousness until they began to draw hard confessional lines between themselves and other monotheists, a process which was perhaps well underway by 660-80 CE and likely strongly supported (if not largely initiated) by the early Umayyads; (6) Muslims were originally motivated to write history exclusively out of a (more or less conscious) desire to provide legitimation for their faith (i.e., Islam, now viewed as a distinct confession), sect (e.g., proto-Sunni or proto-Shi'a), or tribe; (7) although the tradition of early Islamic historical writing is rife with scribal errors, contradictions, fabrications, and distortions, the tradition is generally reliable when it comes to major events that are widely reported at least from the time of the death of Muhammad, and perhaps even from the time of the hijra, though not before the hijra; (8) and, while admittedly difficult, it is possible in many cases to arrive at confident judgments about even minor events and solitary reports in the early Islamic historical tradition.
All of these claims are controversial. For example, many scholars have rejected the traditional Islamic view that the Qur'an dates to the life of Muhammad, arguing instead that it dates to either the time before Muhammad or long after (or perhaps both, with different parts of the Qur'an dating to different periods). On a related note, many scholars have argued that early Islamic historical writing is either completely fictitious or that it is so riddled with errors that it is impossible for modern scholars to tell fact from fiction. In these and other regards, Donner is fairly conservative in his views of early Islamic history and historiography, though of course traditional Muslims will strongly disagree with a number of his claims, including his claim that Muhammad and the first generation of Muslims did not understand themselves to follow a religion distinct from Judaism and Christianity.
I found many of Donner's claims to be strongly supported by his arguments. In particular, I was persuaded by his case for (1)-(3) and (7)-(8). However, I was not convinced by his case for (4)-(6). I am open to the idea that Muhammad did not view himself as the founder of a new religion, but rather the leader of a monotheistic movement that welcomed Jews and Christians as full members. Still, I am not yet convinced by Donner's arguments for this claim. (I should note that Donner presents a more extensive case for the claim in his recent book Muhammad and the Believers than he does in Narratives of Islamic Origins, but I've read the latter book as well, and I'm still not convinced.) At any rate, I believe that many of Donner's arguments for (1)-(3) and (7)-(8) are still extremely plausible - and in some cases even compelling - despite the fact that his arguments for (4)-(6) are not fully convincing. Moreover, given the importance of (1)-(3) and (7)-(8), I think it is clear that Donner's book is incredibly important even if he is wrong about (4)-(6) - and I do not claim that he is wrong about the latter, only that he has not yet convinced me of them. Also, I want to add that while I am not convinced that Muslims were originally motivated to write history exclusively out of concern for legitimation, I believe that Donner has made a strong case that at least a large portion of early Islamic history was so motivated, and I suspect that Donner could agree to a slightly weaker version of this claim without undermining his other arguments, though perhaps he could not accept a significantly weaker version without such a result.
This is not the place to conduct a thorough evaluation of (6), but I would like to register at least one complaint here. Donner claims on pp. 153-54 that the sira literature was likely motivated in large part as a response to Jewish and Christian doubts about Muhammad's prophetic status, with Umayyad concerns for legitimation also playing a significant role. His claim is certainly plausible, but I don't see why it should be any more likely than the hypothesis that the sira literature was motivated largely, if not entirely, by pietistic considerations. It is instructive here to compare the sira literature with the New Testament. Paul's early letters may have been written within thirty years of the death of Jesus, but it took several more decades for the first gospel (Mark) to appear. Are we to suppose that the gospel accounts were largely motivated by a concern to legitimate Christianity as a confessional movement distinct from Judaism, rather than a pietistic concern to proclaim the Gospel of Jesus Christ? I think not, and I expect that many non-Christian scholars of the New Testament will agree with me here. But then why assume that matters were any different when it comes to the sira literature? Granted, parts of the sira literature may have been motivated by various purposes of legitimation, such as a desire to advance sectarian causes, but I see no reason to attribute such motives to the literature as a whole.
There is one more concern about the book that I would like to voice. Although I am inclined to agree with Donner on (7) and (8), I think that the challenges involved in arriving at confident judgments about many events in early Islamic history may be so severe that the game is not worth the effort. Then again, the challenges involved here may be less severe in many cases than those encountered in reconstructing reliable historical narratives from the Old Testament, but I would be strongly hesitant to say that scholars of the Old Testament should consider giving up on their reconstructions of Old Testament history. And I have similar attitudes about historical Jesus studies. So, perhaps the game is worth the effort. Still, I cannot help having some reservations about the pay-off from scholarly debates about who participated in the Battle of Badr, the outcome of the Battle of Siffin, or the leadership qualities of `Uthman ibn `Affan.
Before closing, I should mention that Donner's book contains a wealth of interesting information, as well as some brilliant analysis, about the sources, themes, motives, social contexts, and historical development of early Islamic historical writing. In short, Donner's book is an invaluable resource for early Islamic history and historiography. No reader will be convinced by everything that Donner says, but I found myself agreeing with him more often than not. Finally, I would like to add that Donner is one of the finest academic writers that I have encountered - that his prose is a pleasure to read, that the book is well organized.
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M PDF
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M EPub
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M Doc
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M iBooks
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M rtf
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M Mobipocket
Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing (Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam, No. 14), by Fred M Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar